Of course this isn't a domain that's in high demand. But NameCheap did "thoughtfully" hold onto the registration. (They were the one hosting the parked page.) So if I wanted it back, I'd have to re-register with them. I did. I wasn't too happy about it, but everything worked out ok. I got my domain back, and only had to pay the $10 renewal fee.
Contrast this with GoDaddy. I stupidly didn't renew my rated-best domain before going on an extended vacation. I came back to a similar situation. The domain had expired, but WhoIs showed that GoDaddy still owned the domain. This seems to be standard operating procedure in the domain world. I log into GoDaddy, but I go to renew it they want a $20 "backorder fee". WTF?! But I do want the domain, so I pay the extortion fee thinking it will work like NameCheap.
And I wait for the domain to show up in my account. It doesn't. After a week I contact support. Turns out they already sold the domain to someone else. But they'd be glad to broker a deal where I can buy it back. For a fee. These guys make NameCheap look like heroes.
While I have built up a bit of traffic and inertia behind the old rated-best domain, it's not enough for me to spend any more money trying to get it back. I simply went out and registered rated-best.info. Sure, I need to build up SEO again for the new domain, but it's pretty straightforward to do so. Besides, the old domain only had a Google PageRank of 2.
The funny thing is, the guy who ended up pouncing on my domain also scraped the content and is continuing to host it from his own servers. With all of my Amazon affiliate codes in the links. So I lost the domain, but I continue to get affiliate fees. Cool.
Here is my unabashed promotion of the new domain to help get me some Google juice. Rated Best: the single best product or service in each category.





